Controversas e Incongruências na WD - parte 1

Controversas segundo a WD

Links -> https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Research:Identifying_Controversial_Content_in_Wikidata

Segundo o projeto, as controversas geram conflitos na edição dos claims (assim como os artigo da Wikipedia), isto está refletido em "guerras de edição" e em páginas de discussão sobre o item com maior volume de atualizações. Esta parte seria inerente ao processo social de crowdsourcing e se reflete nos claims.

An edit war occurs when editors who disagree about the content of a page repeatedly override each other's contributions.

Finally we studied the usage of talk pages as a proxy for controversies. Our intuition here was that controversial content could drive long discussions on talk pages. However, we noticed low usage of talk pages on Wikidata, especially when compared to Wikipedia. 

Assim como na WP tem a marcação explícita de artigo em Disputa, que é realizada manualmente, na WD existe um predicado (P1310) que pode ser associado a um claim que indica que existe discordância em relação a uma alegação. 

statement disputed by

Por exemplo, Jesus é considerado uma instância de deidade. Esta alegação é disputada pelo Judaísmo, Ateísmo e Islamismo e é suportada pelo Cristianismo, tem como referência o Novo Testamento. 

Levantamento com a WD de junho/2022

Em relação ao conjunto de CLAIMS potencialmente controversos ou incongruentes (filtrado) temos a seguinte distribuição de predicados com o qualificador P1310 

Predicado	Lista de Alias @en	Quantidade (Predicado)	Quantidade (Qualificador)	Frequencia (Qualificador/Predicado)
P1120	death number,'deaths,'qty fatalities,'number of fatalities,'dead,'qty deaths,'death count,'death toll,'fatalities	115701	1652	1,427818256
P474	country dialing code,'country code,'calling code,'phone code,'dialing code,'telephone code	508	6	1,181102362
P533	military target,'attack target,'target of attack	1514	6	0,3963011889
P3931	copyright ‘owner’,'copyright owner,'proprietor,'licensor	3223	10	0,3102699348
P8031	suicide bomber,'attacker,'accomplice,'criminals,'spree killer,'terrorist,'offender,'criminal perpetrator,'assassin,'agressor,'serial killer,'domestic terrorist,'direct perpetrator,'indirect perpetrator,'robber,'by,'criminal,'victimiser,'thief,'lead by,'perpetrators,'bomber,'kidnapper,'material author,'murderer,'backpack bomber,'wrong-doer,'killer,'victim of,'perpetrated by,'committed by,'contract killer,'torturer,'assailant,'perp,'mass murderer,'culprit	842	2	0,2375296912
P1268	represents organisation,'stands for,'symbolizes,'symbolises	5575	8	0,1434977578
P8010	recovered cases, number of,'number recovered,'recovery, number of cases	17629	18	0,1021044869
P1142	supports political ideology,'political viewpoint,'political view,'ideology,'has political ideology,'official political ideology,'official ideology,'supports ideology,'editorial viewpoint	24135	22	0,09115392583
P1376	administrative seat of,'parish seat of,'county seat of,'is capital of,'county seat for,'seat of	85565	60	0,07012212938
P9071	stock character,'dere,'-dere	3191	2	0,06267627703
P150	has counties,'has towns,'has states,'has local government areas,'has cities,'has regions,'has villages,'divides into,'has shires,'has municipalities,'contains,'has countries,'has wards,'subdivided into,'has districts,'has rural cities,'has boroughs,'has members,'has arrondissements,'divided into,'has administrative divisions	1046411	615	0,05877231795
P41	image of flag,'image flag	46428	25	0,05384681658
P3893	copyright end date,'PD date	2249	1	0,04446420631
P3842	located in the present-day administrative territorial entity,'today part of,'located in the modern-day administrative territorial entity,'located in present day administrative territorial entity,'would today be located in administrative territorial entity,'located in the current administrative territorial entity	21449	8	0,03729777612
P3179	partially contains territorial extent,'partially located in territorial entity,'partly located in territorial entity,'partly overlaps,'partially overlaps,'partially coincident with,'partly coincident with,'overlaps	8532	3	0,03516174402
P1038	co-husband,'grandchildren,'uncle,'relation,'uncle-in-law,'sister-in-law,'co-brother-in-law,'co-sister-in-law,'brother-in-law,'father-in-law,'co-sibling-in-law,'mother-in-law,'niece,'aunt,'co-wife,'collateral descendant,'grandson,'grandchild,'descendant,'granddauther,'cousin,'grandmother,'nephew,'son-in-law,'kinsman,'nibling,'non-binary parent,'grandparent,'aunt-in-law,'family member,'daughter-in-law,'lineal descendant,'family,'grandfather,'ancestor	53332	18	0,03375084377
P767	assistant,'contributor,'collaborator,'creative contributor,'contributor(s) to the subject	41234	13	0,03152738032
P879	hull classification symbol,'pendant number,'hull number	3303	1	0,03027550711
P2389	leader of,'directs,'organization headed by,'head of,'organization directed by,'leads,'organization directed from the office,'organization led by,'directs this organization,'heads,'organization led from the office or person,'runs	13587	4	0,02943990579
P2408	period,'period covered,'set in era,'period of setting,'era of setting,'era set in,'narrative time,'narrative period,'era,'features event,'setting,'takes place in time,'time period,'set in,'significant event,'time period of setting,'time period set in,'set in time,'period set in,'set during	7572	2	0,0264131009
P1299	acted by,'played by,'portrayed by,'depicted in,'appears in	11401	3	0,02631348127
P1308	position holder,'office holder,'incumbent,'position held by,'noble title holder	17797	4	0,02247569815
P1420	taxonomic synonym,'this taxon has as synonym,'synonym of this name	21652	4	0,01847404397
P1332	wikibase:geoLatitude ?max,'coordinate of northernmost point,'northernmost point coordinates,'most northerly,'northerly point,'extreme point north,'farthest north	11945	2	0,01674340728
P941	inspiration,'source of inspiration	6043	1	0,01654807215
P355	daughter organization,'subsidiary entities,'imprint,'subsidiary company,'subordinate body,'owns,'has subsidiary,'subordinate unit,'subsidiary body,'daughter company,'subsidiary organization,'has imprint,'parent company of	93775	15	0,01599573447
P2175	disease treated,'treats medical condition,'treats,'capable of inhibiting or preventing pathological process,'treats disease	6971	1	0,01434514417
P706	geographical region,'is in,'landform,'located on physical feature,'loc (terr),'on geographical feature,'on natural feature,'located on the terrain feature,'located on terrain feature,'on,'location (terrain feature),'takes place in,'is on,'terrain feature	80488	7	0,008696948613
P463	be member of,'member of musical group,'in musical group,'membership,'band member of	444593	38	0,008547143117
P1196	death type,'circumstance of death,'type of death,'nature of death,'death manner	101002	8	0,007920635235
P1855	eg,'Example item for this property,'e.g.,'example of property,'example of Wikidata property,'example,'property sample,'Wikidata property sample,'for example,'property example	26792	2	0,0074649149
P749	superior formation,'parent organisation,'owned by (company or organisation),'subsidiary of,'parent unit,'has organizational parent,'parent company,'parent agency,'part of,'holding,'holding company,'owned by (company or organization)	123208	9	0,007304720473
P1478	is immediately caused by,'has proximate cause,'proximate outcome of,'immediate result of,'immediate effect of,'proximate result of,'proximately caused by,'has proximate causes,'is proximately caused by,'immediately caused by,'proximate effect of,'immediate cause,'has immediate causes,'immediate outcome of	125079	9	0,007195452474
P17	host country,'state,'land,'sovereign state	14996553	999	0,00666153082
P488	headed by,'president,'dean,'leader,'chair,'chairman,'chairwoman	31862	2	0,006277069864
P460	is the same as,'equal to,'similar to,'may be,'could be,'said to be same as,'may be equal to,'same as,'could be equal to,'equivalent of,'the same as,'said to be equal to,'same,'close to,'conspecific with,'equivalent to,'is said to be the same as,'see also	287695	16	0,005561445281
P710	accused,'player,'suspect,'belligerents,'event participant,'party,'participants,'agent,'competitor,'attendee,'between,'has participant	432740	23	0,005314969728
P47	borders clockwise,'next to,'bordered by,'adjacent to,'border	606626	30	0,004945386449
P40	has daughters,'children,'offspring,'son,'has kid,'daughters,'sons,'progeny,'issue,'has sons,'kid,'has kids,'has daughter,'has son,'parent of,'descendants,'has children,'daughter,'has child,'kids	1563655	61	0,003901116295
P1050	health problem,'suffers from,'health issue,'sickness,'illness,'suffer from,'ailment,'condition,'disease,'health condition,'disability,'disorder,'paralympic disability	242080	8	0,003304692664
P559	train station at the end of the line,'end point,'termini,'terminuses,'trailhead,'terminating connection	61172	2	0,003269469692
P50	written by,'by,'writer(s),'author(s),'authors,'writer,'creator,'writers	1635488	50	0,003057191493
P3373	has sister,'is sibling of,'siblings,'half-sister,'brother,'sister or brother,'has sibling,'is brother of,'sisters,'sis,'half-sibling,'sisters and brothers,'is the sibling of,'sib,'brothers,'sibling of,'bro,'is the brother of,'has brother,'is sister of,'brothers and sisters,'sister,'is the sister of,'brother or sister,'half-brother	411175	12	0,002918465374
P131	is in the ward of,'is in the local government area of,'is in administrative unit,'located in administrative unit,'located in the administrative unit,'is in the town of,'is in the Indian reserve of,'is in the department of,'is in the voivodeship of,'is in the commune of,'is in the province of,'is in the parish of,'is in the region of,'based in,'location (administrative territorial entity),'is in the arrondissement of,'locality,'is in the administrative unit,'is in the shire of,'is in the city of,'is in the borough of,'in the administrative unit,'administrative territorial entity,'is in the state of,'is in the municipality of,'in administrative unit,'state,'is located in,'administrative territory,'is in the county of,'is in the district of,'is in the rural city of,'town,'happens in,'is in the administrative region of,'is in the principal area of,'region,'is in the village of,'is in the settlement of,'is in the Indian reservation of,'located in the territorial entity,'in,'is in the territory of,'city,'territory,'is in the prefecture of,'Indian reservation	11371144	310	0,002726198877
P509	die of,'method of murder,'died of,'murder method,'death cause,'die from	116224	3	0,002581222467
P39	political seat,'political office held,'office held,'holds position,'function,'position occupied,'held position,'public office	1485766	37	0,002490297934
P676	author,'words by,'writer (of song lyrics),'lyricist	42037	1	0,002378856721
P1365	succeeds,'deprecates,'predecessor,'continues,'replaced,'supersedes,'previous job holder,'preceded by,'forefather,'continues from	86406	2	0,002314654075
P2635	component count,'consists of x acts,'number of segments of anthology film,'contains x acts,'acts count,'chapter count,'number of acts,'acts number,'number of chapters,'stanza count,'number of pictures,'acts quantity,'consists of x parts,'composed of x acts,'number of tracks on release,'movement count,'number of tracks,'composed of x parts,'chapters quantity,'comprises x parts,'pictures quantity,'number of volumes,'number of movements,'movements quantity,'tracks quantity,'track count,'picture count,'number of stanzas,'number of scenes,'comprises x acts,'number of issues,'number of parts of this work of art,'stanzas quantity,'number of songs	48276	1	0,002071422653
P180	reproduces,'painting of,'portrays,'sounds like,'depicting,'resembles,'presents,'show of,'portrait of,'landscape of,'motif,'pictures,'plot,'depiction of,'shows,'conveys,'represents,'displays,'subject	619426	12	0,001937277415
P576	dissolved on date,'dissolved or abolished,'folded,'dissolved, abolished, or demolished,'date disbanded,'defunct date,'destroyed in,'abolished,'date of termination,'date of cessation,'final year,'ceased to exist,'disbanded on,'disestablished,'publication terminal date,'time of abolishment,'dissolved,'terminal date,'date of demolition,'terminated on,'demolition date,'defunct,'demolished,'terminal issue,'publication end date,'time dissolved,'dissolution date,'abolishment date,'date dissolved,'time of dissolution,'date disestablished,'last issue,'ceased date,'termination date,'ceased publication,'demise date,'wound up on date,'closed on,'time abolished,'closure date,'ended,'cessation date,'final issue,'end date,'razed in,'disbanded,'date of dissolution,'ceased on	238720	4	0,001675603217
P138	named for,'name after,'namesake,'named in honor of,'linked with,'toponym,'etymology,'eponym	375152	6	0,001599351729
P86	composed by,'musical score by,'written by,'songwriter,'film score by,'music by	189590	3	0,001582361939
P1889	often confused with,'different entity from,'distinguished from,'different to,'different thing from,'isn\'t,'not to be confused with,'different entity than,'is different from,'to be distinguished from,'is not the same as,'differs from,'not same as,'disambiguated from,'different than,'do not confuse with,'not identical to,'differ from,'different thing than,'is not,'not equal to,'rejected match,'≠,'is not same as,'distinct from,'confused with,'mistakenly taken for,'not the same as	811803	12	0,001478191138
P512	academic diploma,'degree,'diploma	136844	2	0,001461518225
P94	symbol,'arms,'heraldic representation,'image of coat of arms,'CoA image,'heraldic emblem	137350	2	0,001456133964
P112	founder,'founders,'co-founder,'started by,'cofounded by,'co-founded by,'cofounder,'established by	74571	1	0,001341003876
P84	architecture firm	76135	1	0,00131345636
P1366	continued by,'superseded by,'next job holder,'mediatised to,'successor,'heir,'succeeded by	87375	1	0,001144492132
P22	daughter of,'daddy,'child of,'parent,'is son of,'is daughter of,'has father,'dad,'son of,'is child of	958162	9	0,000939298365
P140	religion or world view,'life stance,'faith,'denomination,'has religion,'follows religion,'follower of religion,'religious affiliation	450242	4	0,0008884111211
P1269	subtopic of,'main topic,'section in,'subitem of,'topic of,'aspect of,'subject in	115848	1	0,0008632000552
P176	built by,'assembler,'provided by,'builder,'mfr,'assembled by,'product of,'produced or manufactured by,'manufactured by,'producer (of product),'made by,'provider,'maker	134768	1	0,0007420159088
P170	painter,'created,'sculptors,'created by,'painters,'sculptor,'made by,'creators,'artist (non-musical)	871782	6	0,0006882454559
P527	created from,'has branch,'holonym of,'divided by,'composed of,'incorporates,'comprised of,'assembled out of,'has parts,'has ingredient,'ingredients,'has part(s),'had part,'formed from,'set of,'has part,'has ingredients,'has component,'has as part,'contains,'formed out of,'includes,'have part,'contain,'parts,'created out of,'consists of,'has member,'amalgamation of,'assembled from,'includes part	1947505	11	0,0005648252508
P156	precedes,'next,'succeded by,'prequel of,'next element,'then,'continued as,'preceeds,'successor,'next is,'sequel is,'comes before	1125386	6	0,0005331504035
P136	type of music,'literary genre,'art style,'music genre,'artistic genre,'genres,'genre of music,'film genre,'kind of music,'type of film	1508670	8	0,0005302683821
P25	daughter of,'mam,'child of,'parent,'is son of,'mummy,'is daughter of,'mom,'mum,'son of,'is child of,'has mother	603918	3	0,0004967561821
P2561	also known as,'label,'aka,'known as,'referred to as,'be referred as,'be known as	206137	1	0,0004851142687
P2094	qualifies for,'disability sport classifications,'class for competition,'compclass,'weight class,'qualification class,'rated at	214951	1	0,0004652223065
P175	artist,'singer,'actress,'actor,'dancer,'played by,'performed by,'recording by,'portrayed by,'recorded by,'sung by,'musician,'musical artist	504429	2	0,0003964879101
P279	is a class of,'whose instances ⊆ those of,'type of,'⊂,'is also a,'is a category of,'sc,'whose instances are among,'way of,'subset of,'is thereby also a,'has superclass,'⊆,'rdfs:subClassOf,'hyponym of,'subtype of,'is a type of,'form of,'subcategory of,'is necessarily also a,'is a subtype of	3296313	13	0,000394380024
P577	air date,'first published,'date of first publication,'pubdate,'date of publication,'dop,'initial release,'publication,'first publication,'released in,'be published during,'airdate,'time of publication,'released,'release date,'date released,'first released,'launched,'broadcast date,'be published in,'was published during,'was published in,'date published,'date of release,'launch date,'published,'year of publication,'publication time	2536217	10	0,0003942880282
P569	birthyear,'born on,'born,'birth year,'birthdate,'year of birth,'DOB,'birth date	5793113	18	0,0003107137734
P26	marry,'wife,'married to,'married,'spouses,'husband,'marital partner,'wives,'marriage partner,'wed,'wedded to,'husbands	732347	2	0,0002730945849
P31	example of,'type,'member of,'is a unique,'is a specific,'distinct individual member of,'is a,'distinct member of,'main type,'has class,'distinct element of,'has type,'rdf:type,'type of,'unique individual of,'is an,'unitary element of class,'is a particular,'is a(n),'is an individual,'∈,'is a type of,'is an example of	59717980	160	0,0002679260082
P155	succeeds,'comes after,'succeeds to,'is after,'previous is,'prequel is,'successor to,'split from,'predecessor,'before was,'previous element,'prev,'preceded by,'sequel of	1133500	2	0,0001764446405
P171	higher taxon,'taxon parent	3613473	6	0,0001660452423
P106	profession,'job,'career,'employment,'work,'employ,'craft,'avocation,'vocation	9608349	13	0,0001352989988
P1448	full title,'legal name,'be named,'long title,'official title,'name,'long name,'registered name,'complete title	1590456	2	0,0001257500993
P1001	applies to place,'belongs to jurisdiction,'linked to jurisdiction,'applicable country,'applies to area,'applicable area,'of jurisdiction,'applicable place,'applied to jurisdiction,'applies to geographic area,'applies to geographic place,'applicable jurisdiction,'jurisdiction,'applicable geographic place,'applicable territorial jurisdiction,'valid in jurisdiction,'country of jurisdiction,'applies to region,'applicable location,'applies to territorial jurisdiction	947743	1	0,0001055138366
P20	POD,'deathplace,'location of death,'died in,'death location,'died,'killed in,'death place	1223012	1	0,00008176534654
P276	is in,'from,'neighborhood,'based in,'place held,'locality,'located,'venue,'locale,'place,'region,'event location,'moveable object location,'in,'location of item,'located in	2613926	2	0,00007651326013
P735	personal name,'middle name,'forename,'name,'first name,'Christian name	6824771	5	0,00007326253145
P19	birthplace,'born in,'location of birth,'born,'born at,'birth city,'POB,'birth place,'location born,'birth location	3064487	2	0,00006526377824
P570	death date,'date of the end,'year of death,'deathdate,'death,'died,'dead,'DOD,'died on	2926895	1	0,00003416589936
P361	contained within,'is part of,'section of,'merged into,'merged with,'cadet branch of,'subassembly of,'part of-property,'system of,'component of,'subsystem of,'chain,'collateral branch of,'meronym of,'subgroup of,'within,'branch of,'element of,'in,'assembly of	4397806	1	0,00002273861103
P27	national of,'subject of (country),'citizenship,'(legal) nationality,'citizen of	4494645	1	0,00002224869817
P625	point on the globe,'gps location,'gps coordinate,'geographic coordinates,'longitude,'co-ordinates,'point on earth,'co-ordinate location,'location on map,'gps co-ordinate,'wgs-84,'geo,'coordinates,'geotag,'latitude,'point on a map,'wgs 84,'coords,'gps co-ordinates,'location,'geocoordinates,'wgs84,'geolocation,'co-ords,'position,'geographic coordinate,'location on earth,'gps coordinates,'gps,'geographical coordinates	9267000	2	0,00002158195748

Em relação ao total de CLAIMS temos a seguinte distribuição

Predicado	Lista de Alias @en	Quantidade (Predicado)	Quantidade (Qualificador)	Frequencia (Qualificador/Predicado)
P474	country dialing code,'country code,'calling code,'phone code,'dialing code,'telephone code	508	3	0,5905511811
P1345	homicides,'number of homicide victims,'kill count,'kills,'number of deaths by the killer	220	1	0,4545454545
P3909	final words	256	1	0,390625
P3886	perpetrators,'assailants	388	1	0,2577319588
P3931	copyright ‘owner’,'copyright owner,'proprietor,'licensor	3223	8	0,2482159479
P8031	suicide bomber,'attacker,'accomplice,'criminals,'spree killer,'terrorist,'offender,'criminal perpetrator,'assassin,'agressor,'serial killer,'domestic terrorist,'direct perpetrator,'indirect perpetrator,'robber,'by,'criminal,'victimiser,'thief,'lead by,'perpetrators,'bomber,'kidnapper,'material author,'murderer,'backpack bomber,'wrong-doer,'killer,'victim of,'perpetrated by,'committed by,'contract killer,'torturer,'assailant,'perp,'mass murderer,'culprit	842	2	0,2375296912
P157	slain by,'executioner,'shot dead by,'slaughtered by,'mortally wounded by,'assassin,'murdered by,'assassinated by,'murderer,'killer,'executed by	3484	5	0,1435132032
P533	military target,'attack target,'target of attack	1514	2	0,1321003963
P1074	fictionalization of,'fictionalisation of,'fictional version of	1977	2	0,1011633789
P9071	stock character,'dere,'-dere	3191	3	0,09401441554
P91	sexuality	4285	4	0,09334889148
P1336	claimed by,'sovereignty claimed by,'territorial claim by	1099	1	0,09099181074
P9759	underpass number,'bridge identifier,'underpass indentifier	2261	2	0,08845643521
P1268	represents organisation,'stands for,'symbolizes,'symbolises	5575	4	0,07174887892
P770	destroyed by,'reason of failure	1394	1	0,07173601148
P3712	end,'objective,'goal,'stated goal,'project of,'intention,'desired result,'purpose,'aim to,'to support,'aim,'desired outcome,'mission	1666	1	0,0600240096
P1636	date baptism,'time of christening,'christened,'baptized,'date of baptism in early childhood,'date of christening,'time of baptism,'baptised,'christening date,'baptism date	3742	2	0,05344735436
P263	state house,'presidential mansion,'home,'executive mansion,'lives at,'domicile,'executive residence,'lives in,'gubernatorial mansion,'resides at,'palace,'presidential palace	2008	1	0,04980079681
P941	inspiration,'source of inspiration	6043	3	0,04964421645
P1557	realization of,'reification of	2131	1	0,04692632567
P3893	copyright end date,'PD date	2249	1	0,04446420631
P3179	partially contains territorial extent,'partially located in territorial entity,'partly located in territorial entity,'partly overlaps,'partially overlaps,'partially coincident with,'partly coincident with,'overlaps	8532	3	0,03516174402
P451	cohabitant,'is the partner of,'significant other,'is partner of,'partners,'domestic partner,'partner,'enbyfriend,'sex partner,'SO,'lover,'partner of,'boyfriend,'life partner,'posslq,'girlfriend,'romantic partner	14280	5	0,0350140056
P1542	has symptom,'result,'causes,'cause of,'consequence,'led to,'effect,'outcome,'implies,'has result,'caused,'has outcome	5841	2	0,03424071221
P879	hull classification symbol,'pendant number,'hull number	3303	1	0,03027550711
P2388	position held by head of the organisation,'chief\'s office,'head\'s office,'president\'s office,'headed by,'secretary\'s office,'CEO\'s office,'office held by head of the organisation,'chairperson\'s office,'head of the organization,'minister\'s office,'directed by / from,'leader\'s office	13340	4	0,0299850075
P2596	civilisation,'archaeological culture	10130	3	0,02961500494
P2389	leader of,'directs,'organization headed by,'head of,'organization directed by,'leads,'organization directed from the office,'organization led by,'directs this organization,'heads,'organization led from the office or person,'runs	13587	4	0,02943990579
P3842	located in the present-day administrative territorial entity,'today part of,'located in the modern-day administrative territorial entity,'located in present day administrative territorial entity,'would today be located in administrative territorial entity,'located in the current administrative territorial entity	21449	5	0,02331111008
P1308	position holder,'office holder,'incumbent,'position held by,'noble title holder	17797	4	0,02247569815
P460	is the same as,'equal to,'similar to,'may be,'could be,'said to be same as,'may be equal to,'same as,'could be equal to,'equivalent of,'the same as,'said to be equal to,'same,'close to,'conspecific with,'equivalent to,'is said to be the same as,'see also	287695	52	0,01807469716
P8010	recovered cases, number of,'number recovered,'recovery, number of cases	17629	3	0,01701741449
P2175	disease treated,'treats medical condition,'treats,'capable of inhibiting or preventing pathological process,'treats disease	6971	1	0,01434514417
P1376	administrative seat of,'parish seat of,'county seat of,'is capital of,'county seat for,'seat of	85565	12	0,01402442588
P2408	period,'period covered,'set in era,'period of setting,'era of setting,'era set in,'narrative time,'narrative period,'era,'features event,'setting,'takes place in time,'time period,'set in,'significant event,'time period of setting,'time period set in,'set in time,'period set in,'set during	7572	1	0,01320655045
P1196	death type,'circumstance of death,'type of death,'nature of death,'death manner	101002	13	0,01287103226
P461	inverse of,'is opposite of,'contrast of,'opposite,'contrasted to,'inverse,'opposite to,'is the opposite of,'has opposite	24473	3	0,01225840722
P1038	co-husband,'grandchildren,'uncle,'relation,'uncle-in-law,'sister-in-law,'co-brother-in-law,'co-sister-in-law,'brother-in-law,'father-in-law,'co-sibling-in-law,'mother-in-law,'niece,'aunt,'co-wife,'collateral descendant,'grandson,'grandchild,'descendant,'granddauther,'cousin,'grandmother,'nephew,'son-in-law,'kinsman,'nibling,'non-binary parent,'grandparent,'aunt-in-law,'family member,'daughter-in-law,'lineal descendant,'family,'grandfather,'ancestor	53332	6	0,01125028126
P509	die of,'method of murder,'died of,'murder method,'death cause,'die from	116224	13	0,01118529736
P828	ultimate cause,'had reason,'caused by,'initial cause,'reason,'outcome of,'implied by,'has underlying cause,'had underlying cause,'ultimate causes,'underlying cause,'due to,'effect of,'cause,'has reason,'why,'result of,'because,'had cause,'has causes,'originated due to	9408	1	0,0106292517
P1420	taxonomic synonym,'this taxon has as synonym,'synonym of this name	21652	2	0,009237021984
P1299	acted by,'played by,'portrayed by,'depicted in,'appears in	11401	1	0,008771160425
P1332	wikibase:geoLatitude ?max,'coordinate of northernmost point,'northernmost point coordinates,'most northerly,'northerly point,'extreme point north,'farthest north	11945	1	0,008371703642
P1142	supports political ideology,'political viewpoint,'political view,'ideology,'has political ideology,'official political ideology,'official ideology,'supports ideology,'editorial viewpoint	24135	2	0,00828672053
P1855	eg,'Example item for this property,'e.g.,'example of property,'example of Wikidata property,'example,'property sample,'Wikidata property sample,'for example,'property example	26792	2	0,0074649149
P1366	continued by,'superseded by,'next job holder,'mediatised to,'successor,'heir,'succeeded by	87375	6	0,00686695279
P488	headed by,'president,'dean,'leader,'chair,'chairman,'chairwoman	31862	2	0,006277069864
P706	geographical region,'is in,'landform,'located on physical feature,'loc (terr),'on geographical feature,'on natural feature,'located on the terrain feature,'located on terrain feature,'on,'location (terrain feature),'takes place in,'is on,'terrain feature	80488	5	0,006212106152
P1120	death number,'deaths,'qty fatalities,'number of fatalities,'dead,'qty deaths,'death count,'death toll,'fatalities	115701	6	0,00518578059
P676	author,'words by,'writer (of song lyrics),'lyricist	42037	2	0,004757713443
P17	host country,'state,'land,'sovereign state	14996553	601	0,00400758761
P1365	succeeds,'deprecates,'predecessor,'continues,'replaced,'supersedes,'previous job holder,'preceded by,'forefather,'continues from	86406	3	0,003471981112
P355	daughter organization,'subsidiary entities,'imprint,'subsidiary company,'subordinate body,'owns,'has subsidiary,'subordinate unit,'subsidiary body,'daughter company,'subsidiary organization,'has imprint,'parent company of	93775	3	0,003199146894
P800	creator of,'notable books,'significance,'famous for,'they discovered,'representative work,'they wrote,'known for,'works,'artwork,'bibliography,'representative of artwork type,'work,'famous works,'major works,'they invented,'they designed,'literary works,'significant works,'famous books,'they created	95659	3	0,00313613983
P86	composed by,'musical score by,'written by,'songwriter,'film score by,'music by	189590	5	0,002637269898
P1050	health problem,'suffers from,'health issue,'sickness,'illness,'suffer from,'ailment,'condition,'disease,'health condition,'disability,'disorder,'paralympic disability	242080	6	0,002478519498
P749	superior formation,'parent organisation,'owned by (company or organisation),'subsidiary of,'parent unit,'has organizational parent,'parent company,'parent agency,'part of,'holding,'holding company,'owned by (company or organization)	123208	3	0,002434906824
P767	assistant,'contributor,'collaborator,'creative contributor,'contributor(s) to the subject	41234	1	0,002425183101
P1478	is immediately caused by,'has proximate cause,'proximate outcome of,'immediate result of,'immediate effect of,'proximate result of,'proximately caused by,'has proximate causes,'is proximately caused by,'immediately caused by,'proximate effect of,'immediate cause,'has immediate causes,'immediate outcome of	125079	3	0,002398484158
P61	invented by,'coined,'created by,'inventor or discoverer,'invented,'developed by,'first described,'inventor,'devised by,'discovered by,'developer,'discoverer,'introduced by	84472	2	0,002367648452
P170	painter,'created,'sculptors,'created by,'painters,'sculptor,'made by,'creators,'artist (non-musical)	871782	19	0,002179443944
P41	image of flag,'image flag	46428	1	0,002153872663
P366	role,'use,'utility,'unit mission,'purpose,'usage,'used as,'used for,'as,'function,'mission,'used in	92867	2	0,002153617539
P39	political seat,'political office held,'office held,'holds position,'function,'position occupied,'held position,'public office	1485766	31	0,002086465836
P2635	component count,'consists of x acts,'number of segments of anthology film,'contains x acts,'acts count,'chapter count,'number of acts,'acts number,'number of chapters,'stanza count,'number of pictures,'acts quantity,'consists of x parts,'composed of x acts,'number of tracks on release,'movement count,'number of tracks,'composed of x parts,'chapters quantity,'comprises x parts,'pictures quantity,'number of volumes,'number of movements,'movements quantity,'tracks quantity,'track count,'picture count,'number of stanzas,'number of scenes,'comprises x acts,'number of issues,'number of parts of this work of art,'stanzas quantity,'number of songs	48276	1	0,002071422653
P144	theme,'cover of,'inherits from,'modelled after,'has parts from,'adaptation of,'copy of,'fork of,'remake of,'derived from,'source work,'extended from,'derivative of,'based upon,'derivative work of,'replica of,'inspired by,'based on work,'themed after,'modeled after,'adapted from,'parody of	53413	1	0,001872203396
P559	train station at the end of the line,'end point,'termini,'terminuses,'trailhead,'terminating connection	61172	1	0,001634734846
P138	named for,'name after,'namesake,'named in honor of,'linked with,'toponym,'etymology,'eponym	375152	6	0,001599351729
P3373	has sister,'is sibling of,'siblings,'half-sister,'brother,'sister or brother,'has sibling,'is brother of,'sisters,'sis,'half-sibling,'sisters and brothers,'is the sibling of,'sib,'brothers,'sibling of,'bro,'is the brother of,'has brother,'is sister of,'brothers and sisters,'sister,'is the sister of,'brother or sister,'half-brother	411175	6	0,001459232687
P94	symbol,'arms,'heraldic representation,'image of coat of arms,'CoA image,'heraldic emblem	137350	2	0,001456133964
P1552	has characteristic,'has property,'inherent property,'attribute,'trait,'defining feature,'defined by,'parameter,'requirement,'characterized by,'required property,'aspect,'defining parameter,'has feature,'quality	69339	1	0,001442189821
P22	daughter of,'daddy,'child of,'parent,'is son of,'is daughter of,'has father,'dad,'son of,'is child of	958162	13	0,001356764305
P112	founder,'founders,'co-founder,'started by,'cofounded by,'co-founded by,'cofounder,'established by	74571	1	0,001341003876
P84	architecture firm	76135	1	0,00131345636
P40	has daughters,'children,'offspring,'son,'has kid,'daughters,'sons,'progeny,'issue,'has sons,'kid,'has kids,'has daughter,'has son,'parent of,'descendants,'has children,'daughter,'has child,'kids	1563655	20	0,001279054523
P576	dissolved on date,'dissolved or abolished,'folded,'dissolved, abolished, or demolished,'date disbanded,'defunct date,'destroyed in,'abolished,'date of termination,'date of cessation,'final year,'ceased to exist,'disbanded on,'disestablished,'publication terminal date,'time of abolishment,'dissolved,'terminal date,'date of demolition,'terminated on,'demolition date,'defunct,'demolished,'terminal issue,'publication end date,'time dissolved,'dissolution date,'abolishment date,'date dissolved,'time of dissolution,'date disestablished,'last issue,'ceased date,'termination date,'ceased publication,'demise date,'wound up on date,'closed on,'time abolished,'closure date,'ended,'cessation date,'final issue,'end date,'razed in,'disbanded,'date of dissolution,'ceased on	238720	3	0,001256702413
P710	accused,'player,'suspect,'belligerents,'event participant,'party,'participants,'agent,'competitor,'attendee,'between,'has participant	432740	5	0,001155428202
P1066	apprentice of,'thesis advisor,'pupil of,'studied under,'master\'s supervisor,'is student of,'professor,'teacher,'supervisor,'tutor,'master\'s advisor,'advisor,'degree advisor,'master,'master\'s thesis advisor,'academic supervisor,'mentor,'degree supervisor,'disciple of	87659	1	0,001140784175
P131	is in the ward of,'is in the local government area of,'is in administrative unit,'located in administrative unit,'located in the administrative unit,'is in the town of,'is in the Indian reserve of,'is in the department of,'is in the voivodeship of,'is in the commune of,'is in the province of,'is in the parish of,'is in the region of,'based in,'location (administrative territorial entity),'is in the arrondissement of,'locality,'is in the administrative unit,'is in the shire of,'is in the city of,'is in the borough of,'in the administrative unit,'administrative territorial entity,'is in the state of,'is in the municipality of,'in administrative unit,'state,'is located in,'administrative territory,'is in the county of,'is in the district of,'is in the rural city of,'town,'happens in,'is in the administrative region of,'is in the principal area of,'region,'is in the village of,'is in the settlement of,'is in the Indian reservation of,'located in the territorial entity,'in,'is in the territory of,'city,'territory,'is in the prefecture of,'Indian reservation	11371144	126	0,001108067931
P26	marry,'wife,'married to,'married,'spouses,'husband,'marital partner,'wives,'marriage partner,'wed,'wedded to,'husbands	732347	7	0,0009558310473
P150	has counties,'has towns,'has states,'has local government areas,'has cities,'has regions,'has villages,'divides into,'has shires,'has municipalities,'contains,'has countries,'has wards,'subdivided into,'has districts,'has rural cities,'has boroughs,'has members,'has arrondissements,'divided into,'has administrative divisions	1046411	10	0,0009556474464
P140	religion or world view,'life stance,'faith,'denomination,'has religion,'follows religion,'follower of religion,'religious affiliation	450242	4	0,0008884111211
P36	administrative capital,'capital town,'government capital,'seat of government,'administrative centre,'government seat,'court residence,'location of capital,'chef-lieu,'principal place,'county town,'county seat,'administrative headquarters,'administrative center,'administrative seat,'has capital,'seat,'capital city	115764	1	0,0008638264054
P1269	subtopic of,'main topic,'section in,'subitem of,'topic of,'aspect of,'subject in	115848	1	0,0008632000552
P1889	often confused with,'different entity from,'distinguished from,'different to,'different thing from,'isn\'t,'not to be confused with,'different entity than,'is different from,'to be distinguished from,'is not the same as,'differs from,'not same as,'disambiguated from,'different than,'do not confuse with,'not identical to,'differ from,'different thing than,'is not,'not equal to,'rejected match,'≠,'is not same as,'distinct from,'confused with,'mistakenly taken for,'not the same as	811803	7	0,0008622781635
P50	written by,'by,'writer(s),'author(s),'authors,'writer,'creator,'writers	1635488	14	0,000856013618
P243	WorldCat accession number,'OCLC number,'OCN	118085	1	0,0008468476098
P25	daughter of,'mam,'child of,'parent,'is son of,'mummy,'is daughter of,'mom,'mum,'son of,'is child of,'has mother	603918	5	0,0008279269702
P180	reproduces,'painting of,'portrays,'sounds like,'depicting,'resembles,'presents,'show of,'portrait of,'landscape of,'motif,'pictures,'plot,'depiction of,'shows,'conveys,'represents,'displays,'subject	619426	5	0,0008071989229
P2043	distance,'size,'dimension,'length overall,'long,'LOA	263736	2	0,0007583340917
P176	built by,'assembler,'provided by,'builder,'mfr,'assembled by,'product of,'produced or manufactured by,'manufactured by,'producer (of product),'made by,'provider,'maker	134768	1	0,0007420159088
P512	academic diploma,'degree,'diploma	136844	1	0,0007307591126
P1477	née,'born as,'bname,'full birth name,'birthname,'full name at birth,'name at birth,'bn,'nee,'maiden name (female)	154122	1	0,0006488366359
P57	directed by,'film director,'movie director	333611	2	0,000599500616
P47	borders clockwise,'next to,'bordered by,'adjacent to,'border	606626	3	0,0004945386449
P2561	also known as,'label,'aka,'known as,'referred to as,'be referred as,'be known as	206137	1	0,0004851142687
P2094	qualifies for,'disability sport classifications,'class for competition,'compclass,'weight class,'qualification class,'rated at	214951	1	0,0004652223065
P242	map,'locator map	219948	1	0,000454652918
P156	precedes,'next,'succeded by,'prequel of,'next element,'then,'continued as,'preceeds,'successor,'next is,'sequel is,'comes before	1125386	5	0,0004442920029
P119	interment location,'location of burial,'remains at,'resting place,'interment place,'grave at,'buried at,'burial place,'cemetery,'entombed at,'place of interment,'burial location,'buried in,'interment,'tomb,'place of grave,'interred at,'ashes scattered at	233721	1	0,0004278605688
P570	death date,'date of the end,'year of death,'deathdate,'death,'died,'dead,'DOD,'died on	2926895	11	0,0003758248929
P582	left office,'ends,'cease operation,'ending,'completed in,'divorced,'enddate,'cease time,'closed,'fall date,'stop time,'dissolved,'till,'until,'to,'cease date,'endtime,'end date	564031	2	0,0003545904392
P155	succeeds,'comes after,'succeeds to,'is after,'previous is,'prequel is,'successor to,'split from,'predecessor,'before was,'previous element,'prev,'preceded by,'sequel of	1133500	4	0,000352889281
P569	birthyear,'born on,'born,'birth year,'birthdate,'year of birth,'DOB,'birth date	5793113	19	0,0003279756497
P279	is a class of,'whose instances ⊆ those of,'type of,'⊂,'is also a,'is a category of,'sc,'whose instances are among,'way of,'subset of,'is thereby also a,'has superclass,'⊆,'rdfs:subClassOf,'hyponym of,'subtype of,'is a type of,'form of,'subcategory of,'is necessarily also a,'is a subtype of	3296313	10	0,0003033692492
P20	POD,'deathplace,'location of death,'died in,'death location,'died,'killed in,'death place	1223012	3	0,0002452960396
P361	contained within,'is part of,'section of,'merged into,'merged with,'cadet branch of,'subassembly of,'part of-property,'system of,'component of,'subsystem of,'chain,'collateral branch of,'meronym of,'subgroup of,'within,'branch of,'element of,'in,'assembly of	4397806	10	0,0002273861103
P463	be member of,'member of musical group,'in musical group,'membership,'band member of	444593	1	0,0002249248189
P793	important event,'event,'main events,'known for,'notable event,'key incident,'sign. event,'outcome,'key event,'notable incident,'big event,'major event,'significant incident,'significant achievment,'fate	460703	1	0,0002170595807
P527	created from,'has branch,'holonym of,'divided by,'composed of,'incorporates,'comprised of,'assembled out of,'has parts,'has ingredient,'ingredients,'has part(s),'had part,'formed from,'set of,'has part,'has ingredients,'has component,'has as part,'contains,'formed out of,'includes,'have part,'contain,'parts,'created out of,'consists of,'has member,'amalgamation of,'assembled from,'includes part	1947505	4	0,0002053910003
P175	artist,'singer,'actress,'actor,'dancer,'played by,'performed by,'recording by,'portrayed by,'recorded by,'sung by,'musician,'musical artist	504429	1	0,000198243955
P1448	full title,'legal name,'be named,'long title,'official title,'name,'long name,'registered name,'complete title	1590456	3	0,000188625149
P137	service operator,'maintainer,'webmaster,'item operator,'operated by,'administrator,'manager,'user,'facility operator,'managed by	541793	1	0,0001845723367
P31	example of,'type,'member of,'is a unique,'is a specific,'distinct individual member of,'is a,'distinct member of,'main type,'has class,'distinct element of,'has type,'rdf:type,'type of,'unique individual of,'is an,'unitary element of class,'is a particular,'is a(n),'is an individual,'∈,'is a type of,'is an example of	59717980	101	0,0001691282927
P19	birthplace,'born in,'location of birth,'born,'born at,'birth city,'POB,'birth place,'location born,'birth location	3064487	4	0,0001305275565
P735	personal name,'middle name,'forename,'name,'first name,'Christian name	6824771	8	0,0001172200503
P1001	applies to place,'belongs to jurisdiction,'linked to jurisdiction,'applicable country,'applies to area,'applicable area,'of jurisdiction,'applicable place,'applied to jurisdiction,'applies to geographic area,'applies to geographic place,'applicable jurisdiction,'jurisdiction,'applicable geographic place,'applicable territorial jurisdiction,'valid in jurisdiction,'country of jurisdiction,'applies to region,'applicable location,'applies to territorial jurisdiction	947743	1	0,0001055138366
P106	profession,'job,'career,'employment,'work,'employ,'craft,'avocation,'vocation	9608349	10	0,0001040761529
P577	air date,'first published,'date of first publication,'pubdate,'date of publication,'dop,'initial release,'publication,'first publication,'released in,'be published during,'airdate,'time of publication,'released,'release date,'date released,'first released,'launched,'broadcast date,'be published in,'was published during,'was published in,'date published,'date of release,'launch date,'published,'year of publication,'publication time	2536217	2	0,00007885760564
P276	is in,'from,'neighborhood,'based in,'place held,'locality,'located,'venue,'locale,'place,'region,'event location,'moveable object location,'in,'location of item,'located in	2613926	2	0,00007651326013
P27	national of,'subject of (country),'citizenship,'(legal) nationality,'citizen of	4494645	3	0,00006674609452
P136	type of music,'literary genre,'art style,'music genre,'artistic genre,'genres,'genre of music,'film genre,'kind of music,'type of film	1508670	1	0,00006628354776
P6216	copyright restriction	1580247	1	0,00006328124654
P171	higher taxon,'taxon parent	3613473	2	0,00005534841412
P625	point on the globe,'gps location,'gps coordinate,'geographic coordinates,'longitude,'co-ordinates,'point on earth,'co-ordinate location,'location on map,'gps co-ordinate,'wgs-84,'geo,'coordinates,'geotag,'latitude,'point on a map,'wgs 84,'coords,'gps co-ordinates,'location,'geocoordinates,'wgs84,'geolocation,'co-ords,'position,'geographic coordinate,'location on earth,'gps coordinates,'gps,'geographical coordinates	9267000	4	0,00004316391497
P734	last name,'surname	4010661	1	0,00002493354587
P18	drawing,'picture,'Image on Wikimedia Commons,'illustration,'portrait,'img,'graph,'image capture,'screenshot,'File:,'photo,'screen capture,'image of subject,'Image on Commons,'still,'image of exterior,'Commons image	4423081	1	0,00002260867481
P21	gender expression,'biological sex,'gender identity,'sex,'gender	8083032	1	0,00001237159521

Os predicados com mais de 10 CLAIMS associados ao disputed by são 

Predicado	Lista de Alias @en	Quantidade (Qualificador)
P17	host country,'state,'land,'sovereign state	601
P131	is in the ward of,'is in the local government area of,'is in administrative unit,'located in administrative unit,'located in the administrative unit,'is in the town of,'is in the Indian reserve of,'is in the department of,'is in the voivodeship of,'is in the commune of,'is in the province of,'is in the parish of,'is in the region of,'based in,'location (administrative territorial entity),'is in the arrondissement of,'locality,'is in the administrative unit,'is in the shire of,'is in the city of,'is in the borough of,'in the administrative unit,'administrative territorial entity,'is in the state of,'is in the municipality of,'in administrative unit,'state,'is located in,'administrative territory,'is in the county of,'is in the district of,'is in the rural city of,'town,'happens in,'is in the administrative region of,'is in the principal area of,'region,'is in the village of,'is in the settlement of,'is in the Indian reservation of,'located in the territorial entity,'in,'is in the territory of,'city,'territory,'is in the prefecture of,'Indian reservation	126
P31	example of,'type,'member of,'is a unique,'is a specific,'distinct individual member of,'is a,'distinct member of,'main type,'has class,'distinct element of,'has type,'rdf:type,'type of,'unique individual of,'is an,'unitary element of class,'is a particular,'is a(n),'is an individual,'∈,'is a type of,'is an example of	101
P460	is the same as,'equal to,'similar to,'may be,'could be,'said to be same as,'may be equal to,'same as,'could be equal to,'equivalent of,'the same as,'said to be equal to,'same,'close to,'conspecific with,'equivalent to,'is said to be the same as,'see also	52
P39	political seat,'political office held,'office held,'holds position,'function,'position occupied,'held position,'public office	31
P40	has daughters,'children,'offspring,'son,'has kid,'daughters,'sons,'progeny,'issue,'has sons,'kid,'has kids,'has daughter,'has son,'parent of,'descendants,'has children,'daughter,'has child,'kids	20
P170	painter,'created,'sculptors,'created by,'painters,'sculptor,'made by,'creators,'artist (non-musical)	19
P569	birthyear,'born on,'born,'birth year,'birthdate,'year of birth,'DOB,'birth date	19
P50	written by,'by,'writer(s),'author(s),'authors,'writer,'creator,'writers	14
P1196	death type,'circumstance of death,'type of death,'nature of death,'death manner	13
P509	die of,'method of murder,'died of,'murder method,'death cause,'die from	13
P22	daughter of,'daddy,'child of,'parent,'is son of,'is daughter of,'has father,'dad,'son of,'is child of	13
P1376	administrative seat of,'parish seat of,'county seat of,'is capital of,'county seat for,'seat of	12
P570	death date,'date of the end,'year of death,'deathdate,'death,'died,'dead,'DOD,'died on	11
P150	has counties,'has towns,'has states,'has local government areas,'has cities,'has regions,'has villages,'divides into,'has shires,'has municipalities,'contains,'has countries,'has wards,'subdivided into,'has districts,'has rural cities,'has boroughs,'has members,'has arrondissements,'divided into,'has administrative divisions	10
P279	is a class of,'whose instances ⊆ those of,'type of,'⊂,'is also a,'is a category of,'sc,'whose instances are among,'way of,'subset of,'is thereby also a,'has superclass,'⊆,'rdfs:subClassOf,'hyponym of,'subtype of,'is a type of,'form of,'subcategory of,'is necessarily also a,'is a subtype of	10
P361	contained within,'is part of,'section of,'merged into,'merged with,'cadet branch of,'subassembly of,'part of-property,'system of,'component of,'subsystem of,'chain,'collateral branch of,'meronym of,'subgroup of,'within,'branch of,'element of,'in,'assembly of	10
P106	profession,'job,'career,'employment,'work,'employ,'craft,'avocation,'vocation	10